Page 1 of 1

New Wip ...

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2011 1:04 pm
by rosstheboss
My new wip from my latest project ... comment anyone ... ?

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2011 1:22 pm
by rosstheboss
the pic

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Sun Jun 26, 2011 2:02 pm
by Janusz Biela
...still nothing :wink:
ok now see :)

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 9:52 pm
by salvatore
for me:
1- too flat grass
2- too clean all surfaces
3- flip poly cars because i don't see shadows!
4- too similar trees
5- add background
6- too synthetic people
7- too dark shadows and too flat render
8- too poor reflect glass and too yellow
9- non gradient in surfaces
:evil:

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 9:57 pm
by salvatore
and:
10- too similar cars and colours
11- missing striped road
12- missing street furniture
:evil: :evil:

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 10:04 pm
by jure
ok those are all valid points. But the image is not all bad. I think the general lighting is good and background buildings look good too.

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 11:19 pm
by rosstheboss
Thanks for those comments, as sonn as i applied them i'll post the renders with the changes...

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Wed Jun 29, 2011 9:27 am
by ideart
As you have mentioned it's a wip so I am expecting a nice final render after all the good advices from the other users.
I would like to add a suggestion, please change the camera position, you'll get a much nicer result from somewhere near the eye level.
Also, if you keep the 3d people put them faraway from the camera, try inside the building to get a more look alive feeling without revealing to much detail.

Re: New Wip ...

Posted: Mon Jul 04, 2011 11:43 pm
by Alexos
Ok, I don't know what your settings are - looks like a very small, very bright area light - but there's waaaaay too much direct lighting in that image - and harsh! It looks like the sun has turned into a blue giant or something... it's an interesting effect actually, but generally the clients tend to want more reassuring, pink-tinted sunlight :)

There's also something I don't quite understand going on - the tiny white stripes in the shadow areas? What's that? They're superimposed to the central tree as well - weird.

As per the image in itself - those cars don't look good. Nevermind the two identical FIATs which I'm sure you'll move, but they all have the same overblown interior (still a consequence of the lighting, I presume) and they're too reflective. Oh and they're bottomless :)

The three trees to the right... you're going to change those, right? When you do, make them a little smaller perhaps, they're way too big for the small space they're in and they make it look sad and abandoned. Also, the palm trees need a little ground to grow from - as it is now they seem to be planted straight into the pavement, which I suppose is not the case. And finally, the background building to the far right also seems to be "just there" - it needs some pavement, a sidewalk, the usual stuff, and it desperately needs some windows :)
It also looks like your asphalt material has very high spec and very low gloss, which is generally not the case... but having said all that, I really like the overall feel of the image. It's- different! That steely sky has an almost cyberpunk quality to it...

ADP.